Merson Questions Arteta's Response to Dowman's Red Card
Commentary·October 28, 2026

Arsenal's exit from the EFL Cup at the hands of Fleetwood Town has produced a debate that goes beyond the scoreline, and the focus has shifted to the sending off of Max Dowman and how Mikel Arteta handled it.
Paul Merson, who spent years at Arsenal as a player and has since become one of the sharpest voices in British punditry, said he was unhappy with the manager's reaction. In his view, the response did not match the situation, and he suggested it sent the wrong signal at a time when the club needs its younger players to feel supported.
Merson's criticism is a reminder that red cards in cup football carry consequences well beyond the 90 minutes. A dismissal can disrupt a team's shape, leave a player facing a suspension and put a manager under pressure to explain his decisions in public. Arteta now has to answer for both the defeat and the way he responded to it.
Merson's comments are likely to be picked up across the Arsenal fanbase, where opinions on Dowman and the wider squad remain divided. Arsenal have not yet been quoted at length on the matter in the reports available, so it remains to be seen whether Arteta addresses the criticism directly.
Reporting based on an external source.